Comparison between Instrument Ranges, and more

[🎶Lachesis]

Hello.

I plan on making a comprehensive guide on how 3MLE gives us limitations on how wide are the ranges 

of each instrument, and how it compares to the actual in-game limitations. Maybe there is one which isnt the same.

Also, most importantly, this will help us compare the different Instrument Ranges.

This is to avoid, for example, submitting a song that works in 3MLE, but then the SSR (kindly) notice that one note is missing

because the real in-game limitations are different.

 

I would love to have everyone's contribution, specially on getting together the data and comparison for each instrument.

Maybe when its done we can make it into a full fledged comparison guide.

To start it off, from my experiences with the Lyre

 

3MLE top note it can play:  o6 g+

3MLE bottom note it can play: o0 a

In-game top note it can play: o6 g+

In-game bottom note it can play: ???

 

And with the Lute:

3MLE top: o7 e

3MLE bottom: o1 e

In-game top: ??

In-game bottom: ??

Edited December 21, 2015 by Lachesis

[🎶Flameberge]

guitar o0 E to o8 D+

[🎶DJSulfrus]

Is there actually an instance of an observed difference in the ranges on 3mle and in game? That's what I want to know.

3mle and in game Tuba

Bottom o1 C ~ anything below will be silent.

Top o4 b ~ anything above will start from o3 C and up until it goes silent at o8c.

 

Edited December 22, 2015 by DJSulfrus

[🎶Lachesis]

Well, I thought there was a difference, but It was me being mistaken.

But maybe on less used instruments there is observed differences, thats why I dont rule it out yet.

 

Ty you all for the quick contributions.

Once we have a few more we will organize and lump all together ♥

 

[🚩Blargel]

I don't mean to rain on your parade but...

http://wiki.mabinogiworld.com/view/User:LexisMikaya/MML_101_Guide/Instrument_Ranges

[🎶DJSulfrus]

I don't mean to rain on your parade but...

http://wiki.mabinogiworld.com/view/User:LexisMikaya/MML_101_Guide/Instrument_Ranges

That List does not have tuba ranges.

[Mikaya]

That List does not have tuba ranges.

lmao...inserting now.

I am genuinely baffled as to how I missed it to begin with.

Edited December 22, 2015 by Mikaya

[🎶Lachesis]

Awesome. 

I dont mind if there is a list already.

As long as it is made even more available to us.

Maybe if we get a direct link to that guide?

So this topic can be closed too, then.

Ty everyone for the help ♥

P.S. Does that list have Harp already?

[Mikaya]

Awesome. 

I dont mind if there is a list already.

As long as it is made even more available to us.

Maybe if we get a direct link to that guide?

So this topic can be closed too, then.

Ty everyone for the help ♥

P.S. Does that list have Harp already?

I added Harp as soon as I saw it was released. I also added all the other instruments from the other MSXSpirit.dls files last night. You can do w/e with the list of instrument ranges I made for my MML 101 guide. 

Edited December 22, 2015 by Mikaya

[🎶Lachesis]

I meant, I am glad there is a list already, and I dont mind this little project being shut down, since we can 

just get directed to your guide.

 

I think it might be best to do that.

Sorry for not expressing in the clearest way.